"Worst Speech in the History of Democracy?"We can cut Bobby Jindal a little slack over his terrible GOP response to Obama last night (which an apoplectic David Brooks described "as the worst speech in the history of democracy"). The piece was obviously recorded before Jindal had any idea what Obama would say, so every point he made was off by a mile. But the fact is, the content and tone of Obama's speech were no big head-scratcher; every commentator on the airwaves and cable has been speculating for days, mostly correctly, on what Obama would say. Does the Gov. of Louisiana ever listen to anybody but Sean Hannity and Rush Limbaugh? Has he gotten his DTV converter hooked up?
The Jindal "response" was more of a campaign speech than a response to Obama's masterful speech to Congress. Starting with praise for a country that has won civil rights for minorities, he swung into his own family's immigrant experience (I didn't really care to know that he was a fetal immigrant.). His father's phrase, "Americans can do anything" became an annoying verbal mosquito buzzing my ears every few seconds. He also started, oh, about seven points with "To strengthen our economy..." followed by some idiotic GOP idiotic b.s. Like cutting taxes is the cure for everything. Well, hey, if Joe the Bricklayer doesn't have a job, he's not paying taxes anyhow, so how does a tax cut help him?
Another recurrent -- and woefully misguided -- trope in Jindal's speech was, "You can't trust government to run things." It's blatantly obvious that most of the things that have gotten us into this pretty kettle of fish occurred during the Shrub Administration. So what he was really saying, as Paul Krugman later remarked, was, "You can't trust Republicans to run things." Good point, Bobby.
In response to Obama's having made the middle of the political spectrum his own, the GOP is faced with the choice of either going along or going more weirdly right-wing. Jindal has chosen the latter, as have Sarah Palin and other GOP wannabes. The heck with the polls. They know what has killed the Republican Party is not utter incompetence, dirty dealing and nastiness, but a failure to adhere to Goldwater Republicanism. Uh, really?
In this article, Paul Begala opines that Bobby Jindal (and perhaps other Republicans) should stop listening to Rush. Good idea.